| First | Last | Country | 1995-1996 Player of the Year Points |
| Olle | Rade | Sweden | 50 |
| Shawn | Regnier | United States | 41 |
| Mark | Justice | United States | 37 |
| Michael | Loconto | United States | 34 |
| Sean | Fleischman | United States | 31 |
| Preston | Poulter | United States | 31 |
| Tom | Chanpheng | Australia | 30 |
| Scott | Johns | United States | 30 |
| Thomas | Guevin | United States | 27 |
| Bertrand | Lestree | France | 26 |
| Eric | Tam | Canada | 25 |
| Leon | Lindback | Sweden | 24 |
| Henry | Stern | United States | 23 |
| Darwin | Kastle Mess | United States | 22 |
| Alvaro | Marques | Canada | 22 |
| Peter | Radonjic | Canada | 22 |
| Mark | Venhaus | United States | 21 |
| George | Baxter | United States | 15 |
| Matt | Place | United States | 14 |
| John | Immordino | United States | 12 |
| Javier | Garavito | United States | 11 |
| Vaughn | Sandor | United States | 11 |
| Brian | Weissman | United States | 11 |
| Christopher | Bishop | United States | 10 |
| Tommi | Hovi | Finland | 10 |
| David | Humpherys | United States | 10 |
| Jeffrey | Wood | United States | 10 |
| Dennis | Bentley | United States | 9 |
| Michael | Long | United States | 8 |
| Bruce | Swiney | United States | 8 |
| Andrea | Redi | Italy | 7 |
| Thomas | Andersson | Sweden | 6 |
| Alexander | Blumke | Switzerland | 6 |
| Mark | Chalice | United States | 6 |
| Michael | Dove | United States | 6 |
| David | Dittmer | United States | 5 |
| Bryan | McKinty | Canada | 5 |
| MacKenzie | Patterson Jr | United States | 5 |
| Toshiki | Tsukamoto | Japan | 5 |
| Kurt | Burgner | United States | 4 |
| Dominic | Crapuchettes | United States | 4 |
| Erno | Ekebom | Finland | 4 |
| Paul | Ferker | United States | 4 |
| Jon | Finkel | United States | 4 |
| Frederik | Foure | United States | 4 |
| Frank | Gilson | United States | 4 |
| Matt | Hyra | United States | 4 |
| Jim | Len | United States | 4 |
| Paul | McCabe | Canada | 4 |
| Brad | Mennell | United States | 4 |
| Chris | Pikula | United States | 4 |
| Nathan | Wildgrube | United States | 4 |
| Bo | Bell | United States | 3 |
| Adam | Green | United States | 3 |
| Mark | Hendrickson | United States | 3 |
| Nick | Hsieh | United States | 3 |
| James | McGovern | United States | 3 |
| Ward | Ahders | United States | 2 |
| Patrick | Albro | United States | 2 |
| Marc | Aquino | United States | 2 |
| David | Bachmann | United States | 2 |
| Ondrej | Baudys | Czech Republic | 2 |
| Chris | Berryman | United States | 2 |
| Brian | Bouton | United States | 2 |
| Joshua | Bradford | United States | 2 |
| Scott | Burke | United States | 2 |
| Homero | Caballero | Mexico | 2 |
| Steve | Clarys | Belgium | 2 |
| Jan Maarten | Cobben | Netherlands | 2 |
| Alan | Comer | United States | 2 |
| Sean | Conway | United States | 2 |
| Bryce | Currence | United States | 2 |
| Thierry | Dallacroce | United States | 2 |
| Steve | Easton | England | 2 |
| Amiel | Feldman | Switzerland | 2 |
| Evan | Gridley | United States | 2 |
| Kevin | Grubb | United States | 2 |
| Peter | Gysemans | Belgium | 2 |
| Shannon | Hill | United States | 2 |
| Cory | Jones | United States | 2 |
| David | Korejtko | Czech Republic | 2 |
| Rick | Latham | United States | 2 |
| Laurent | Lebas | France | 2 |
| Robert | Lugiano Jr. | United States | 2 |
| Scott | Martin | United States | 2 |
| Chris | McMahon | United States | 2 |
| Cary | Newburger | United States | 2 |
| Andreas | Nyborg | Denmark | 2 |
| David | Price | United States | 2 |
| Jeff | Pysher | United States | 2 |
| Derek | Rank | United States | 2 |
| Mario | Robaina | United States | 2 |
| Ryan | Rusaw | Canada | 2 |
| Rob | Salmon | England | 2 |
| Arjan | Salomons | Netherlands | 2 |
| Jakub | Slemr | Czech Republic | 2 |
| Michael | Sochon | France | 2 |
| Bill | Sperounis | United States | 2 |
| Freek | Ten Cate | Netherlands | 2 |
| Szabolcs | Toszegi | Hungary | 2 |
| Matthew | Vienneau | Canada | 2 |
| Guilherme | Vilar Couto | Brazil | 2 |
| Jamie | Wakefield | United States | 2 |
| Matthew | Wang | United States | 2 |
| Roy | Aberkrom | Netherlands | 1 |
| Bakos | Attila | Hungary | 1 |
| CIZmentine | Bagieu | France | 1 |
| David | Bartholow | United States | 1 |
| Sturla | Bingen | Norway | 1 |
| Matt | Bordeaux | United States | 1 |
| Dennis | Brown | United States | 1 |
| Steve | Brown | United States | 1 |
| Don | Catanzaro | United States | 1 |
| John | Chinnock | United States | 1 |
| Nate | Clarke | United States | 1 |
| David | Clemmer | United States | 1 |
| Franz | Couderc | France | 1 |
| Zak | Dolan | United States | 1 |
| Niklas | Eriksson | Sweden | 1 |
| Matthew | Ferrelli | United States | 1 |
| Svend | Geertsen | Denmark | 1 |
| Andrew | Gillen | Canada | 1 |
| Lucas | Gonzalez | United States | 1 |
| David | Goodnuff | United States | 1 |
| Peter | Guevin | United States | 1 |
| Neil | Guthrie | Sweden | 1 |
| Brian | Hacker | United States | 1 |
| Lee | Hansen | United States | 1 |
| Marc | Hernandez | France | 1 |
| Gabe | Higa | United States | 1 |
| Minh | Huynh | United States | 1 |
| Adam | Jansen | United States | 1 |
| Heath | Jennings | United States | 1 |
| Thomas Dall | Jensen | Denmark | 1 |
| Hiroki | Katsuya | United States | 1 |
| Jeffrey | Kostick | United States | 1 |
| Oliver | Krebs | Germany | 1 |
| Steve | Kuhn | United States | 1 |
| Frederic | Lenoir | Switzerland | 1 |
| Rich | Lipman | United States | 1 |
| Rafael | Lirag | Philippines | 1 |
| Dan | Lofgren | United States | 1 |
| Martin | Ludecke | Germany | 1 |
| Adam | Maysonet | United States | 1 |
| Lee | McLain | United States | 1 |
| Aaron | Muranaka | United States | 1 |
| Mike | Murphy | United States | 1 |
| Jean-Luc | Park | United States | 1 |
| Andrea | Paselli | Italy | 1 |
| Trenton | Pratt | United States | 1 |
| Gunnar | Refsdal | Germany | 1 |
| Scott | Reinfeld | United States | 1 |
| Henning | Rimkus | Germany | 1 |
| Ken | Roth | United States | 1 |
| Viktor | Rovo | Hungary | 1 |
| Sven | Runing | United States | 1 |
| Brandon | Rutter | United States | 1 |
| Oliver | Schneider | England | 1 |
| Craig | Sheppard | Australia | 1 |
| Kirk | Simmons | United States | 1 |
| Rune | Speich | Denmark | 1 |
| Justin | Stiles | United States | 1 |
| Michael | Suwald | Switzerland | 1 |
| Dominic | Symens | Belgium | 1 |
| Jeremiah | Tollman | United States | 1 |
| Gabriel | Tsang | Canada | 1 |
| Terry | Tsang | Canada | 1 |
| Yoshiyuki | Tsuruta | Japan | 1 |
| Peter | Turcotte | Canada | 1 |
| Joel | Unger | United States | 1 |
| Jesse | Vadnais | United States | 1 |
| Stephan | Valkyser | Germany | 1 |
| David | Van Dijck | Belgium | 1 |
| Mu-Luen | Wang | Austria | 1 |
| Edward | Willis | United States | 1 |
| James | Wise | United States | 1 |
| Worth | Wollpert | United States | 1 |
| John | Yoo | United States | 1 |
| Seyil | Yoon | Canada | 1 |
| Barry | Young | United States | 1 |