column

Pro Tour-Hollywood 2008

Standard By The Numbers

  • Boards
  • Print
Author Image

 HOLLYWOOD DECKLISTS  
  • Top 8 Decklists
  • Day 2 Decklists
  • Day 1 Decklists, A-M
  • Day 1 Decklists, N-Z
  • Pro Tour–Hollywood has come and gone. Charles Gindy reminded us what Sol Malka tried to tell us so many years ago and Uri Peleg confirmed last December: green and black is an extremely powerful combination. The Pros are done with Standard for now (with the exception of a Grand Prix in Buenos Aires) and are leaving it to those of us looking to earn an invitation to our National Championships. If you're one of those many, you've probably busied yourself with the task of reading and re-reading the coverage from the Pro Tour, looking to learn what the Pros thought and how they made their deck choices, and trying to get the benefits of their hard work while also trying to see what went wrong.

    I have taken this information directly from the coverage, copying each round's results into an Excel file and then adding in the deck choice of each player (thanks to all the decklists being posted). As is frequently the case, the winning deck is not necessarily the winningest deck. The more popular a deck is, the harder it is for that deck to have the best winning percentage. Without any further statistical generalizations, let's get to the numbers. First and foremost, a breakdown by archetype:

    Deck Players Percent Avg Rank Avg Winnings
    Doran 31 8.36% 172.9 $738.39
    Merfolk 27 7.28% 175.78 $1,133.33
    Blue-white Lark 16 4.31% 149.25 $317.81
    Red-green Aggro 14 3.77% 217.5 $0.00
    Faeries 103 27.76% 202.17 $347.91
    Red-green Ramp 10 2.70% 176.7 $1,050.00
    Black-green Elves 46 12.40% 195.17 $1,436.96
    Red Deck Wins 45 12.13% 193.44 $215.11
    Green-white Ramp 7 1.89% 152.86 $244.29
    ELVES! 7 1.89% 169.57 $778.57
    Black-red Tokens 6 1.62% 117.17 $650.00
    Juniper Combo 6 1.62% 201.67 $0.00
    Quick 'N Toast 5 1.35% 85 $2,040.00
    Black-green Ramp 4 1.08% 204 $0.00
    NY Red-green 4 1.08% 109 $515.00
    Monogreen Elves 4 1.08% 133.5 $0.00
    Mannequin 4 1.08% 181.25 $0.00
    Black-red Aggro 3 0.81% 161 $0.00
    Kithkin 3 0.81% 283.33 $0.00
    Chapin Combo 3 0.81% 227 $0.00
    Gassy Knoll 3 0.81% 255.33 $0.00
    Black-blue-green Rock 3 0.81% 138 $416.67
    Green-white Aggro 3 0.81% 188.67 $0.00
    Reveillark Combo 3 0.81% 24 $7,846.67
    Black-green Rock 2 0.54% 226.5 $0.00
    Wizards 1 0.27% 197 $0.00
    All Creatures 1 0.27% 51 $645.00
    5-color Elementals 1 0.27% 194 $0.00
    Predator 1 0.27% 230 $0.00
    Red-black Aggro 1 0.27% 32 $1,350.00
    Red-blue-black 1 0.27% 332 $0.00
    Blue-black Aggro 1 0.27% 320 $0.00
    Blue-white Kithkin 1 0.27% 284 $0.00
    Black-green-white Rebels 1 0.27% 162 $0.00

    No surprise here, Faeries was the most represented deck at the tournament, and by a significant margin. Looking a little closer though, we can see that there are several decks that fall under a broader umbrella of archetype. When we widen the camera lens, we see a different story:

    Category Players Percent Avg Rank Avg Earnings
    Merfolk 27 7.28% 175.78 $1,133.33
    Aggro 26 7.01% 212.54 $51.92
    Big Mana 21 5.66% 173.95 $581.43
    Reveillark 19 5.12% 129.47 $1,506.58
    Combo 12 3.23% 221.42 $0.00
    Faeries 103 27.76% 202.17 $347.91
    Black-green 82 22.10% 185.43 $1,100.49
    Elves 11 2.96% 156.45 $495.45
    Burn 45 12.13% 193.44 $215.11
    Black-red 6 1.62% 117.17 $650.00
    Other 6 1.62% 203.33 $107.50
    Quick 'N Toast 5 1.35% 85 $2,040.00
    Mannequin 4 1.08% 181.25 $0.00
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 4 1.08% 109 $515.00

    Rock-like decks narrowed the gap with the Fae, though still falling short in the popularity contest. Look at the difference in average ranks: 185 vs. 202. Black-green decks averaged almost exactly a middle position (371 players). That translated into about $1,100 per Black-green player. Of course, about half of that all went to one person. The story gets even more interesting when we look at the split between Days One and Two:

    Category Total Day2 Day1 Pct Day 2 Pct Delta
    Faeries 103 29 27.76% 21.80% -5.96%
    Black-green 82 29 22.10% 21.80% -0.30%
    Burn 45 16 12.13% 12.03% -0.10%
    Merfolk 27 15 7.28% 11.28% 4.00%
    Reveillark 19 10 5.12% 7.52% 2.40%
    Aggro 26 7 7.01% 5.26% -1.74%
    Big Mana 21 7 5.66% 5.26% -0.40%
    Elves 11 4 2.96% 3.01% 0.04%
    Black-red 6 4 1.62% 3.01% 1.39%
    Quick 'N Toast 5 4 1.35% 3.01% 1.66%
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 4 3 1.08% 2.26% 1.18%
    Combo 12 2 3.23% 1.50% -1.73%
    Mannequin 4 2 1.08% 1.50% 0.43%
    Other 6 1 1.62% 0.75% -0.87%

    Faeries showed the biggest change in representation, dropping almost 6 percent of the market share. That slack was mostly picked up by Merfolk, with Reveillark, Black-red, Quick 'N Toast, and Red-Green Mana Ramp decks all pitching in. Other notable losers are combo and straight aggressive decks. Rock-like decks, while losing marginal ground on the field as a whole, jumped up into a tie for most-popular. They have a shot at homecoming queen after all!

    So we have a pretty good sense of what the landscape of the tournament was, now let's start getting to the fun stuff: how did these decks perform? Bear in mind that all win percentages were done excluding mirror matches (which, by definition, will be 50 percent).

    Deck Win % Matches
    Faeries 47.17% 706
    Red Deck Wins 49.10% 387
    Black-green Elves 49.32% 369
    Doran 50.49% 307
    Merfolk 50.18% 273
    Blue-white Lark 54.60% 174
    Red-green Aggro 43.85% 130
    Red-green Ramp 52.63% 95
    Black Red Tokens 57.14% 77
    Green-white Ramp 52.00% 75
    ELVES! 53.52% 71
    Quick 'N Toast 63.24% 68
    NY Red-green 58.18% 55
    Juniper Combo 45.10% 51
    Reveillark Combo 71.43% 49
    Mannequin 46.81% 47
    Monogreen Elves 54.05% 37
    Black-green Ramp 47.06% 34
    Black-blue-green Rock 58.06% 31
    Black-red Aggro 48.39% 31
    Green-white Aggro 50.00% 30
    Chapin Combo 35.71% 28
    Kithkin 30.00% 20
    Gassy Knoll 36.84% 19
    Red-black Aggro 68.75% 16
    All Creatures 62.50% 16
    Black-green Rock 43.75% 16
    Wizards 50.00% 8
    5-color Elementals 50.00% 8
    Black-green-white Rebels 50.00% 8
    Predator 42.86% 7
    Blue-white Kithkin 33.33% 6
    Red-blue-black 20.00% 5
    Blue-black Aggro 25.00% 4

    Or broken out by our familiar categories:

    Category Win % Matches
    Faeries 47.17% 706
    Black-green 50.08% 637
    Burn 49.10% 387
    Merfolk 50.18% 273
    Aggro 45.13% 226
    Reveillark 58.53% 217
    Big Mana 51.52% 198
    Elves 53.77% 106
    Combo 40.82% 98
    Black-red 57.14% 77
    Quick 'N Toast 63.24% 68
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 58.18% 55
    Other 49.02% 51
    Mannequin 46.81% 47

    Well, I don't know about you but I certainly didn't think Faeries were going to be the fourth-worst deck choice, behind the ubiquitous "Other." A surprise "best" deck shows up in Quick 'N Toast. I'm going to hesitate to call it the best deck though, for a couple of reasons. First, let's be honest for a moment. There were five players playing the deck, some of whom you may have heard of: Guillaume Matignon, Manuel Bucher, Guillaume Wafo-Tapa, and the brothers Ruel. The deck had a pretty impressive pedigree in its favor, boasting close to 900 lifetime Pro Points. Any deck whose entire pilot crew has an average of 180 Pro Points is doing just fine. So, while the deck certainly did well, I'm going to go on the record as saying that it is very likely that there were some games where the deck underperformed but was pulled through by the pilot. Second, it was a surprise deck, especially in Day 1. Nobody had ever heard of it, nor knew how to play against it. As time went by and people learned what was in it, they got better at playing against it and the win percentage went down. Don't believe me? Take a look at this:

    Day Win % Matches
    Total 63.24% 68
    One 68.42% 38
    Two 56.67% 30
    Quick 'N Toast won close to 70 percent of its matches on Day 1, which dropped drastically to 57 percent on Day 2. That's still a very strong showing, so don't discount the deck entirely...just be aware that some of the surprise factor has been washed away.

    Looking at the rest of the field, it appears that Reveillark, Mana Ramp, Black-red and Elves decks performed best. Our winner, Black-green, ended up at just a shade over a 50/50 pick. Notice that of the top five performers, Reveillark is the only one to represent more than 5 percent of the field. These decks were, by and large, unexpected or unplanned for by the population. We're going to examine each of these, in addition to some of the more widely used strategies to see where their strengths and weaknesses are.

    Quick 'N Toast

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Total 68.42% 38 56.67% 30 63.24% 68
    Faeries 50.00% 12 55.56% 9 52.38% 21
    Black-green 88.89% 9 42.86% 7 68.75% 16
    Burn 100.00% 4 75.00% 4 87.50% 8
    Big Mana 75.00% 4 100.00% 2 83.33% 6
    Reveillark 75.00% 4 0.00% 2 50.00% 6
    Aggro 50.00% 2 n/a 0 50.00% 2
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 100.00% 1 n/a 0 100.00% 1
    Merfolk 0.00% 1 50.00% 4 40.00% 5
    Black-red 0.00% 1 n/a 0 0.00% 1
    Mannequin n/a 0 100.00% 1 100.00% 1
    Elves n/a 0 100.00% 1 100.00% 1

    With Q'NT, we can see that there was absolute dominance of Black-green, Big Mana decks, and Burn decks. It had decent game against Faeries, and nothing exciting against Merfolk. No truly bad pairings are apparent.

    Reveillark

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Day 3 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Total 55.94% 143 64.79% 71 33.33% 3 58.53% 217
    Faeries 46.81% 47 36.36% 11 n/a 0 44.83% 58
    Black-green 58.97% 39 72.22% 18 0.00% 1 62.07% 58
    Burn 60.00% 15 83.33% 12 n/a 0 70.37% 27
    Merfolk 36.36% 11 36.36% 11 0.00% 1 34.78% 23
    Aggro 75.00% 8 33.33% 3 n/a 0 63.64% 11
    Big Mana 80.00% 5 100.00% 2 100.00% 1 87.50% 8
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 75.00% 4 66.67% 3 n/a 0 71.43% 7
    Quick 'N Toast 25.00% 4 100.00% 2 n/a 0 50.00% 6
    Elves 100.00% 3 100.00% 1 n/a 0 100.00% 4
    Combo 33.33% 3 100.00% 1 n/a 0 50.00% 4
    Black-red 100.00% 2 100.00% 3 n/a 0 100.00% 5
    Other 100.00% 1 100.00% 2 n/a 0 100.00% 3
    Mannequin 100.00% 1 50.00% 2 n/a 0 66.67% 3

    Reveillark went the opposite direction of Toast, bringing some serious game on Day 2 to the tune of almost a 9 percent better win percentage. Day Three? Don't ask. Reveillark is very solid against most of the possible pairings, but there are two very dubious ones lingering in there: Faeries is a bad matchup, and Merfolk is just miserable. Those two accounted for about a third of the field.

    Red-Green Mana Ramp

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Total 58.06% 31 58.33% 24 58.18% 55
    Faeries 75.00% 8 75.00% 8 75.00% 16
    Reveillark 25.00% 4 33.33% 3 28.57% 7
    Merfolk 66.67% 3 100.00% 3 83.33% 6
    Burn 66.67% 3 66.67% 3 66.67% 6
    Black-green 66.67% 3 25.00% 4 42.86% 7
    Aggro 100.00% 2 50.00% 2 75.00% 4
    Combo 50.00% 2 n/a 0 50.00% 2
    Elves 50.00% 2 n/a 0 50.00% 2
    Other 100.00% 1 n/a 0 100.00% 1
    Mannequin 0.00% 1 n/a 0 0.00% 1
    Big Mana 0.00% 1 0.00% 1 0.00% 2
    Quick 'N Toast 0.00% 1 n/a 0 0.00% 1

    A consistent performer across both days, the mana ramp decks (featuring Magus of the Moon and Deus of Calamity) were positioned well to take advantage of a Faerie-heavy field. Look at these numbers though, and you see some very dominating numbers followed by some very depressing numbers. This is a pure metagame deck. If you're expecting Merfolk and Faeries, bring some forests and mountains. If you think it'll be Black-green and Reveillark, it's best to leave them home.

    Black-red

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Total 60.00% 45 53.13% 32 57.14% 77
    Faeries 50.00% 12 42.86% 14 46.15% 26
    Black-green 77.78% 9 100.00% 6 86.67% 15
    Burn 66.67% 6 50.00% 4 60.00% 10
    Big Mana 75.00% 4 50.00% 2 66.67% 6
    Merfolk 50.00% 4 n/a 0 50.00% 4
    Combo 0.00% 3 n/a 0 0.00% 3
    Aggro 100.00% 2 100.00% 2 100.00% 4
    Mannequin 100.00% 2 n/a 0 100.00% 2
    Reveillark 0.00% 2 0.00% 3 0.00% 5
    Quick 'N Toast 100.00% 1 n/a 0 100.00% 1
    Elves n/a 0 0.00% 1 0.00% 1

    Here's a deck that correctly anticipated the amount of Rock-esque decks showing up and probably was hoping a good number of Faerie decks wouldn't make it to Day 2. Those hopes were not realized however, with more matches against Faeries in Day 2 than Day 1 while less total matches were played. That led to the 60% / 53% split for Days One and Two.

    Elves

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Total 57.89% 76 43.33% 30 53.77% 106
    Black-green 66.67% 24 71.43% 7 67.74% 31
    Faeries 65.22% 23 40.00% 10 57.58% 33
    Burn 66.67% 9 0.00% 3 50.00% 12
    Merfolk 62.50% 8 50.00% 4 58.33% 12
    Big Mana 0.00% 3 50.00% 2 20.00% 5
    Reveillark 0.00% 3 0.00% 1 0.00% 4
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 50.00% 2 n/a 0 50.00% 2
    Combo 50.00% 2 n/a 0 50.00% 2
    Mannequin 0.00% 1 n/a 0 0.00% 1
    Aggro 0.00% 1 n/a 0 0.00% 1
    Black-red n/a 0 100.00% 1 100.00% 1
    Other n/a 0 0.00% 1 0.00% 1
    Quick 'N Toast n/a 0 0.00% 1 0.00% 1

    Talk about a Day 1 deck! From eight points on the good side of 50 percent to seven on the bad side! This one is truly baffling. It wasn't the result of playing all good pairings on Day 1 and bad ones on Day 2. These were with very similar pairings: 65 percent against Faeries on Day 1, 40 percent against Faeries on Day 2. It would seem that there was a learning curve against these decks. It should be noted that these are the monogreen and token variants of the elf decks, not the Rock-like black-green ones. It is possible that people just "figured it out" after playing against and/or seeing some matches.

    Faeries

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Day 3 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Total 47.53% 526 46.37% 179 0.00% 1 47.17% 706
    Black-green 48.70% 154 32.65% 49 0.00% 1 44.61% 204
    Burn 35.96% 89 47.62% 21 n/a 0 38.18% 110
    Aggro 50.00% 52 62.50% 8 n/a 0 51.67% 60
    Merfolk 45.10% 51 44.00% 25 n/a 0 44.74% 76
    Reveillark 53.19% 47 63.64% 11 n/a 0 55.17% 58
    Big Mana 57.14% 42 57.14% 14 n/a 0 57.14% 56
    Elves 34.78% 23 60.00% 10 n/a 0 42.42% 33
    Combo 80.95% 21 100.00% 3 n/a 0 83.33% 24
    Black-red 50.00% 12 57.14% 14 n/a 0 53.85% 26
    Quick 'N Toast 50.00% 12 44.44% 9 n/a 0 47.62% 21
    Other 33.33% 9 0.00% 2 n/a 0 27.27% 11
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 25.00% 8 25.00% 8 n/a 0 25.00% 16
    Mannequin 50.00% 6 60.00% 5 n/a 0 54.55% 11

    The dark cloud that was hanging over the Standard metagame prior to the Pro Tour has been lifted, and this is how. Fairy decks cannot handle Burn, Elf, Merfolk, Mana Ramp, or Rock decks. They can, however, handle just about everything else. If you have your Bitterblossoms and are determined to use them in Regionals, you should be looking at shoring up those matchups.

    Black-green (Rock)

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Day 3 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Total 49.78% 460 50.29% 173 75.00% 4 50.08% 637
    Faeries 51.30% 154 67.35% 49 100.00% 1 55.39% 204
    Burn 57.35% 68 50.00% 26 n/a 0 55.32% 94
    Aggro 58.54% 41 46.15% 13 n/a 0 55.56% 54
    Merfolk 48.78% 41 57.14% 21 50.00% 2 51.56% 64
    Reveillark 41.03% 39 27.78% 18 100.00% 1 37.93% 58
    Big Mana 42.86% 35 46.15% 13 n/a 0 43.75% 48
    Elves 33.33% 24 28.57% 7 n/a 0 32.26% 31
    Combo 64.71% 17 25.00% 4 n/a 0 57.14% 21
    Other 58.33% 12 0.00% 1 n/a 0 53.85% 13
    Quick 'N Toast 11.11% 9 57.14% 7 n/a 0 31.25% 16
    Black-red 22.22% 9 0.00% 6 n/a 0 13.33% 15
    Mannequin 75.00% 8 50.00% 4 n/a 0 66.67% 12
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 33.33% 3 75.00% 4 n/a 0 57.14% 7

    And here is your champion. The most stunning thing to me in looking at this is the huge gap from Days One to Two in how Rock-ly decks handled the Fae. It was plus-16 percent against the same deck, both with ample matches played (so no low sample-size explanation) seems very suspect to me. It is hard to imagine that they just figured out how to play against Faeries, as that was presumably the deck they spent the most time testing against. I have to guess that something else was at play here, perhaps the Black-green decks in Day 2 simply had better prepared sideboards.

    Also interesting is that Rock-ing decks were sufficiently owned by Reveillark, but failed to win the most important match in the Top 8.

    Merfolk

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Day 3 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Total 53.18% 173 44.33% 97 66.67% 3 50.18% 273
    Faeries 54.90% 51 56.00% 25 n/a 0 55.26% 76
    Black-green 51.22% 41 42.86% 21 50.00% 2 48.44% 64
    Burn 60.00% 20 27.78% 18 n/a 0 44.74% 38
    Aggro 41.18% 17 33.33% 3 n/a 0 40.00% 20
    Reveillark 63.64% 11 63.64% 11 100.00% 1 65.22% 23
    Elves 37.50% 8 50.00% 4 n/a 0 41.67% 12
    Big Mana 42.86% 7 33.33% 6 n/a 0 38.46% 13
    Combo 60.00% 5 0.00% 1 n/a 0 50.00% 6
    Black-red 50.00% 4 n/a 0 n/a 0 50.00% 4
    Other 100.00% 3 100.00% 1 n/a 0 100.00% 4
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 33.33% 3 0.00% 3 n/a 0 16.67% 6
    Mannequin 50.00% 2 n/a 0 n/a 0 50.00% 2
    Quick 'N Toast 100.00% 1 50.00% 4 n/a 0 60.00% 5

    Here's another deck that started off strong but fell down on Day 2—most of it is from an 8.5 percent dropoff against Black-green and a 32 percent (gulp!) dropoff against Burn decks between days. If those two matches had remained steady, Merfolk would have maintained its overall 53 percent winning percentage. Big Mana, Burn, Aggro, and Elves were unsurprisingly the biggest headaches for the fish.

    Burn

    Opponent Deck Category Day 1 Win % Matches Day 2 Win % Matches Total Win % Total Matches
    Grand Total 47.99% 273 51.75% 114 49.10% 387
    Faeries 64.04% 89 52.38% 21 61.82% 110
    BG 42.65% 68 50.00% 26 44.68% 94
    Aggro 55.00% 20 63.64% 11 58.06% 31
    Merfolk 40.00% 20 72.22% 18 55.26% 38
    Big Mana 25.00% 16 37.50% 8 29.17% 24
    Reveillark 40.00% 15 16.67% 12 29.63% 27
    Combo 63.64% 11 50.00% 2 61.54% 13
    Elves 33.33% 9 100.00% 3 50.00% 12
    Mannequin 28.57% 7 100.00% 2 44.44% 9
    BR 33.33% 6 50.00% 4 40.00% 10
    Other 20.00% 5 n/a 0 20.00% 5
    Quick 'N Toast 0.00% 4 25.00% 4 12.50% 8
    Red-Green Mana Ramp 33.33% 3 33.33% 3 33.33% 6

    Burn was the third-most played category archetype in the field and showcased a significant advantage against a couple of the most-played archetypes. However, sub-.500 records against Reveillark, Big Mana, and Black-green didn't help its cause. But it sure taught Faeries a lesson or two!

    Finally, I wanted to see if there was any kind of relationship between a deck's performance and the stage of the tournament. Below are some of our Top 8 decks and how their categories did throughout the tournament.

    Nothing really concrete shown here. Black-green seems to be the most consistent, hovering around 50 percent for the duration with the exception of a hiccup in Rounds 12 and 13. Big Mana was on the biggest roller coaster throughout the tournament.

    In the end, there was no deck that was a clear favorite against the entire field. Quick 'N Toast and Reveillark both were close, but had some holes to fill in. Good luck at your Regionals, I'm hoping to get some data for analysis on those tournaments so hopefully you'll be hearing from me soon.

    • Planeswalker Points
    • Facebook Twitter
    • Gatherer: The Magic Card Database
    • Forums: Connect with the Magic Community
    • Magic Locator